Home / Blog / New customer campaigns
AppLovin BFCM

AppLovin New Customer Campaigns: What to Do After Cyber Monday

Why Prospecting and Discovery should stay live in December, how to judge them on D7 and D14, and how to keep the buyers BFCM brought in.

A glowing yellow-green shopping bag on a dark surface with soft haze, lit from behind
After Cyber Monday, the buyers you just acquired are the start of the payback, not the end of the campaign.

AppLovin new customer campaigns should stay live after Cyber Monday. AppLovin's own BFCM 2025 data shows new customers drove most holiday checkouts, and that Prospecting and Discovery campaigns keep adding value for up to 14 days after the click. Brands that cut these campaigns on December 1 judge them on the weakest window and switch them off just as the results come in.

This guide covers what changes after Cyber Monday 2026 (Monday, November 30), which AppLovin campaign type to use for new versus returning customers, how to read D0, D7 and D14 results, what to do with budgets and creative in December, and how to turn holiday buyers into repeat customers.

The short version

  • Keep Prospecting and Discovery live after Cyber Monday. AppLovin advises against cutting budgets sharply the week after.
  • Use Prospecting or Discovery for new customers and Universal for returning customers, with separate goals.
  • Treat D0 as an early signal, D7 as a checkpoint and D14 as the main call for new-customer campaigns.
  • Make bigger budget changes at 12:00 AM UTC, when campaigns reset, and only cut a campaign that is missing its target at D14.
  • Keep adding creative every week and move from sale messages to product messages when the offer ends.
  • Plan follow-up for holiday buyers beyond 90 days. In AppLovin's data, repeat purchases kept growing to day 270.

What changes after Cyber Monday

Three things happen in the first week of December. Demand drops from its peak, most sale offers end, and a large group of first-time buyers has just entered your customer file. Each one pushes brands toward the same mistake: cutting every campaign back to October levels at once.

AppLovin's BFCM 2026 Part 2 article (Sue Deng and Shirley Deng, October 5, 2026) is clear on the first point. In BFCM 2025, new-customer checkouts on AppLovin reached 3.3x the evergreen baseline, against 2.9x for returning customers, and new customers made up the majority of checkouts across major categories. Average order value was roughly the same for both groups. The authors advise keeping campaigns live on the new-customer pool rather than cutting budgets sharply the week after Cyber Monday.

The data behind that advice is AppLovin's own advertiser data from BFCM 2025. The article gives no sample size or control group, so read it as platform guidance, not a controlled study. It still matches what we see in practice: the cohort you bought during the sale is still maturing in December, and the campaigns that found it still have value after the sale.

If you are still planning the sale itself, our AppLovin BFCM playbook covers the run-up. This post starts where that one ends.

Prospecting, Discovery and Universal: which one finds new customers

AppLovin Ads has three campaign types for web advertisers, and they differ in who they look for. AppLovin's Discovery launch post (Jack Armand, February 25, 2026, updated July 28, 2026) defines them this way.

Campaign typeOptimizes forBest use after Cyber Monday
UniversalTotal conversion performance, new and returningKeep returning customers and recent site visitors covered
ProspectingNew purchasers, including visitors who have not bought yetKeep finding first-time buyers while December demand lasts
DiscoveryPurchases from people who have never interacted with the brandReach people with no site visit, browse or cart history

AppLovin's BFCM guidance follows the same split: use Prospecting and Discovery to capture new-customer demand, use Universal to keep returning-customer coverage, and set separate goals for each. Discovery uses the same historical purchase data as Prospecting, so a brand already running Prospecting is already set up for it. Shopify stores share that data through the AppLovin app.

The practical point for December is not to merge everything into one Universal campaign to save effort. A merged campaign will lean toward the cheapest conversions, which are often returning buyers who were going to come back anyway. Keeping the new-customer campaigns separate keeps the new-customer goal visible. For more on how the three types differ, see our AppLovin Discovery campaigns guide.

Judge new-customer campaigns on D7 and D14, not D0

The most common post-sale mistake is reading new-customer campaigns on day-0 numbers. AppLovin's BFCM 2025 data shows how much that undersells them. New-customer ROAS grew from D0 to D14 by:

Campaign typeNew-customer ROAS growth, D0 to D14 (BFCM 2025)
Universal29%
Prospecting63%
Discovery78%

The campaigns built for new customers gain the most after day 0. That makes sense: someone who has never heard of your brand often needs more time and a second visit before buying. AppLovin's advice is to use D0 as an early signal, D7 as a checkpoint, and to let Prospecting and Discovery run through D14 before making the main call. It also says not to cut or move budget based on the first few days when the goal is new-customer ROAS or cost per purchase.

Applied to December, a Discovery campaign that looks weak on December 2 is being judged on sales from people who first saw the ad during Cyber Week and have not finished deciding yet. Wait until D14 data for those days is in, around mid-December, before deciding to cut it. Our Day 0 vs Day 7 optimization guide explains how these windows work in AppLovin reporting.

Budgets in December: hold, then adjust on the reset

AppLovin's guidance is to avoid sharp cuts the week after Cyber Monday. It does not give a figure for how much to keep, and its general optimizing guide does not cover lowering budgets or seasonality at all. So the rules below combine what AppLovin does say with our own approach, which we label as such.

What AppLovin says, from its "Optimizing your web campaign" guide:

  • Make larger budget changes at 12:00 AM UTC, when campaigns reset, so the change spreads evenly across the day.
  • Scale only when a campaign is consistently hitting its goals, and raise budgets in small daily steps while performance holds.
  • Evaluate performance at the campaign level.
  • Launch fresh creative alongside bigger budget increases to avoid fatigue.

How we apply it after Cyber Monday (our approach, not AppLovin policy):

  1. Hold new-customer campaigns for the first week. Bring sale-level budgets down in steps on the 12:00 AM UTC reset rather than in one cut, and keep Prospecting and Discovery running.
  2. Set December targets from D7 and D14, not D0. A target set on day-0 ROAS will look missed for campaigns that mature later.
  3. Cut only on D14 evidence. If a new-customer campaign is still well below target once its D14 data is in, reduce it. If it is on target, keep it near its pre-sale level.
  4. Shift some returning-customer spend. Universal campaigns can come down faster after the sale, because many of the people they reach just bought.

Budget changes also change what you are charged each day. If you plan a large step down or back up, our AppLovin billing guide explains when AppLovin charges your card.

Creative for December: new ads every week, new messages after the sale

AppLovin's BFCM 2026 Part 3 article (October 7, 2026) looks at November 2025 creative and BFCM 2025 results. AppLovin describes the results as observational, meant to guide planning rather than guarantee outcomes. Three findings matter for December:

  • Fresh creative performed better. Advertisers who added new creative almost every week of November had 23% higher median BFCM D7 ROAS. Creative uploaded in November had 15% higher D7 ROAS than creative more than 60 days old.
  • Short video helped new-customer results most. New-customer D0 ROAS rose 83% during BFCM for videos of 15 seconds or less, against 39% for 16 to 29 seconds and 24% for 30 seconds or longer.
  • HTML end cards beat static images. HTML Interactive end cards improved new-customer ROAS by 58% at D7, against 14% for static image end cards.

One caution on length: AppLovin's optimizing guide also says the top 5% of ads on the platform average 37 seconds. The 15-second finding is about the BFCM lift, not a rule that short always wins. We keep both lengths in a set and let spend show the answer.

The bigger December change is the message. Promotion-led ads took 62.2% of BFCM spend in AppLovin's data. Once the sale ends, a "40% off ends tonight" video is out of date and can mislead. Replace sale creative with product-led versions of your best hooks: what the product does, who it is for, and gift timing while shipping deadlines allow. Keep proven ads running while new ones come in, as AppLovin recommends, and do not pause a creative just because it is not the top spender. AppLovin lists pausing too soon as a common mistake. Our AppLovin end cards guide covers how to rebuild end cards for a new message.

Turning BFCM buyers into repeat customers

The holiday cohort only pays back if some of it buys again. AppLovin reports the cumulative repeat-purchase rate for customers acquired during BFCM: 9.4% by day 90, 12.5% by day 180 and 14.5% by day 270. Cumulative rates can only rise over time and there is no comparison group, so read these as a sense of timing, not a benchmark to hit. The useful point is that repeat buying keeps building well past January.

AppLovin suggests following up with BFCM buyers through a welcome and product guidance, then replenishment reminders, loyalty benefits and recommendations. It does not tie these to a channel. In practice, most of this runs through email, SMS and on-site messages, while AppLovin's role is the paid side:

  • Universal keeps recent buyers and visitors covered for a second purchase.
  • Prospecting and Discovery keep their new-customer goals, so they keep looking for people who have not bought yet.
  • Your own reporting should tag BFCM buyers as a cohort so you can see their 30, 60 and 90-day repeat rates next to the ad spend that found them.

That cohort view is what tells you whether the holiday spend was worth it. A campaign that looked expensive on D0 in late November can look very different once its buyers' second orders are counted.

A 6-step plan for the four weeks after Cyber Monday

  1. December 1 to 7: keep Prospecting and Discovery live. Step budgets down gradually on the 12:00 AM UTC reset instead of one cut. Swap sale creative for product-led versions as offers end.
  2. December 1 to 7: check reporting is set to show D7 and, where available, D14 results for new-customer goals. Do not cut on D0.
  3. Each week: add new creative, keep proven ads live, and include at least one short video and one HTML end card per set.
  4. Around December 14: make the main call on Cyber Week new-customer campaigns using D14 data. Reduce the ones well below target, hold the ones on target.
  5. Mid to late December: bring Universal down faster than new-customer campaigns, since much of its audience just bought.
  6. January: report the BFCM cohort's repeat rate at 30 and 60 days, and plan retention for the 90 to 270 day window where AppLovin's data shows repeat buying keeps growing.

If you want a second view on your post-BFCM setup, our AppLovin agency team can review your campaign mix, targets and creative before you make the December cuts.

FAQ

Should I turn off AppLovin campaigns after Cyber Monday?

No. AppLovin advises keeping campaigns live on the new-customer pool rather than cutting budgets sharply the week after Cyber Monday. Bring budgets down in steps and judge new-customer campaigns on D7 and D14 results before cutting any of them.

Which AppLovin campaign is best for new customers?

Prospecting and Discovery. Prospecting optimizes for new purchasers, including visitors who have not bought yet. Discovery goes further and targets people who have never interacted with your brand. Universal optimizes for total conversions, new and returning.

How long should I wait before judging a Prospecting or Discovery campaign?

AppLovin recommends using D0 as an early signal, D7 as a checkpoint and D14 for the main decision. In its BFCM 2025 data, new-customer ROAS grew 63% from D0 to D14 for Prospecting and 78% for Discovery.

When should I change AppLovin budgets?

AppLovin recommends making larger budget changes at 12:00 AM UTC, when campaigns reset, so the change spreads evenly across the day. That is 7:00 PM Eastern on the previous day during standard time.

Do I need new creative after Black Friday?

Yes. Sale-specific ads go out of date when the offer ends. AppLovin's November 2025 data also showed that advertisers adding creative almost every week had 23% higher median BFCM D7 ROAS. Move to product-led versions of your best hooks and keep adding new ads weekly.

Free checklist

Get the AppLovin launch checklist

The five things we have ready before every first AppLovin test, on two pages. Free, straight to your inbox.

One quick email to confirm, then the checklist. Unsubscribe anytime.

Planning your AppLovin December?

Book a 30-minute call. We will review your post-BFCM campaign mix, budgets and creative plan and tell you what to keep running.

Book a 30-minute call →

Sources

Facts in this article were checked against these sources on November 18, 2026.

  1. AppLovin, "BFCM 2026 Part 2: Black Friday is your biggest new-customer opportunity" (October 5, 2026)
  2. AppLovin, "BFCM 2026 Part 3: Four creative decisions that drive results" (October 7, 2026)
  3. AppLovin, "Optimizing your web campaign" (undated resource page)
  4. AppLovin, "Introducing Discovery Campaigns for AppLovin advertisers" (February 25, 2026, updated July 28, 2026)